Home > fantasy, Genre, horror > Book Review: The Wind Through the Keyhole by Stephen King (Series, #4.5)

Book Review: The Wind Through the Keyhole by Stephen King (Series, #4.5)

Tiger in a cage overlooking a gorge.Summary:
There’s a tale we have yet to hear about the ka-tet in the time between facing the man in the green castle and the wolves of the Calla.  A time when the ka-tet hunkered down and learned a special billy-bumbler talent, an old tale of Gilead, and the first task Roland faced as a young gunslinger after the events at Mejis.

When I heard there was going to be a new Dark Tower book, I had basically three reactions. 1) Yay! 2) Shit he better not ruin them. 3) Guess I didn’t actually finish that series after all, did I? May have written the series review a bit too soon…..

But mainly my reaction was a skeptical excitement.  I love the world of the Dark Tower and was ecstatic to be able to get more of it (yes, I know there are the young gunslinger comic books, but they feel slightly less the same to me since they are in a different format).  However, I was also terrified because well we’ve all been in an instance where we mess with something that was good to the point where it’s not good anymore, right?  I was worried King was going to do that to the Dark Tower.  I am so so so happy to be able to say that worry was unfounded.

This book goes to show just how clearly the entire world of the Dark Tower series exists in King’s mind.  The format is a story within a story within a story.  The ka-tet have to hunker down to wait out a storm, so Roland starts to tell them a story from when he was a young gunslinger.  Within that story, the young Roland tells someone else an old story of Gilead.  The Gilead story wraps up, then the young gunslinger, then the ka-tet.  A writer must know his world very well to be able to handle such a structure smoothly without confusing his reader, and King does just that.  There was no confusion and each story felt fully told. Or as fully told as anything is in the world of the Dark Tower.

I’ve said before that every book in the series basically is a different genre, which is part of what makes it so fun.  So what genre is this one?  I’d say it’s fairy tales. Once upon a times.  And fairy tales generally have a lesson to be learned within them, so what is it in these three?  Well, they vary, but I would say overall it’s about leaving aside childish things and childish ways to become an adult.  (And, I might add, that happens much much earlier in the Dark Tower than it does in our particular world).

I will say, although I certainly had the impression that this book was going to be about Jake and Oy, it really isn’t.  It isn’t much about the ka-tet at all.  It’s about Roland and the role of billy-bumblers in the world.  Although, personally I wanted more billy-bumblers, but I *always* want more billy-bumblers, because they are definitely my favorite fantastical creature.  I’m still holding out hope that King will write something sometime entirely about Oy or billy-bumblers.  But this book is not it.

That said, I was oddly not disappointed to see far less of the ka-tet than I was expecting, because the two stories within the frame of the ka-tet are so strongly told.  They are just….wow. Terrifying, horrifying, unpredictable, and hilarious simultaneously.

That’s the thing that makes any Dark Tower book fun.  It contains all of those things.

Lines can go from laugh out loud humor (with a touch of truth):

Turn yer ears from their promises and yer eyes from their titties. (page 43)

To the starkly sad truth:

Those were good years, but as we know—from stories and from life—the good years never last long. (page 110)

To the simply universal:

“What if I fail?” Tim cried.
Maerlyn laughed. “Sooner or later, we all do.” (page 255)

*shrugs* I admit I’m a bit of a fan girl of the series, but even a fan girl can be sorely disappointed, and I was really and truly not disappointed at all.  I laughed, I nodded, I wondered, I quaked, I wished for an illustration sometime somewhere of billy-bumblers dancing in a clearing in the moonlight.  Although, speaking of illustrations, how gorgeous is the US kindle cover?! So fucking gorgeous, that’s how.

Back to the point, I was not disappointed at all. I was ultimately elated and wishing for more. And other fans will be too.

5 out of 5 stars

Source: Amazon

Buy It

Books in Series:
I’m listing all of the books so you can easily see where The Wind Through the Keyhole falls.
The Gunslinger (review)
The Drawing of the Three (review)
The Waste Lands (review)
Wizard and Glass (review)
The Wind Through the Keyhole
Wolves of the Calla (review)
Song of Susannah (review)
The Dark Tower (review)
Series Review (written before we knew there would be more)

  1. July 26, 2012 at 12:10 pm

    I love your comment on how each book is a different genre, it’s something I hadn’t thought about before, but true.

    I was torn about this book. I read the whole series, all but the final book multiple times. I didn’t reread The Dark Tower, because I basically felt I closed the door on the series, which is my all time favorite series, and wasn’t sure if I could revisit it, at least not any time soon.

    Since finishing the book, a change in job and other circumstance has lead me to do the majority of my reading in audio. So, I struggled whether to do this book in audio or print. I ended up listening, and despite the fact that Stephen King is no where near a great narrator, for me it worked. I think if I had listened to the previous books, it would have been different, but I had always heard this book in my mind in SK voice.

    I’m glad other Dark Tower fans seem to love this book as well. And, someday, there needs to be a Billy Bumbler book.

    • July 26, 2012 at 12:34 pm

      Thank you! It hit me when I read Wizard and Glass and was like “ewwww,” and a friend pointed out to me that I hate romance. That’s when I realized that each one is a different genre.

      I had no idea that King narrates the audiobooks himself! I’d try that out, but I can’t do that in a series in which I’ve already established the characters’ voices for myself in my head. Maybe one of his shorter (haha) books I’ll try out just to hear how he does it.

      I can get why people are torn. Personally I just love the world King has created so much that it doesn’t matter to me that he keeps coming back to it. But I get why it could possibly bug others. Or at least the fact that this one inserts itself into the previously complete ka-tet 7 book series, whereas something like Salem’s Lot is part of the story but separate

      Gods I hope he does a billy-bumbler! I hope he sees everyone asking for it and gives us one!

  2. Kor
    August 4, 2012 at 2:06 pm

    Nice review, I haven’t read this one yet. I loved the Gunslinger so will make sure i read the entire series.. I can’t imagine how each book would fit into a different genre though! I will have to read to find out. Currently I’m reading through stephen book best books list and currently reading Different seasons as recommended in this Stephen King books list.

    • August 4, 2012 at 5:00 pm


      Most people who like The Gunslinger stick it out with the rest of the series and at least *moderately* like it, so I do hope you’ll finish it!

  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: