Home > Book Review, Genre, Length - average but on the shorter side, memoir > Book Review: Made in China: A Memoir of Love and Labor by Anna Qu

Book Review: Made in China: A Memoir of Love and Labor by Anna Qu

Image of a digital bookcover. A yellow background with scissor open to cut three threads over it. The title of the book is in black. The author's name is in blue.

When Anna Qu was in high school, she had her guidance counselor call child protective services because her mother was making her work without pay in the family sweatshop. In her memoir, she explores how her life went from living with her grandparents in China while her widowed mother pursued success in America to the level of division and problems with her mother that led to calling CPS. An exploration of sweatshops, immigration, and difficult relationships with family of origin.

I was immediately intrigued by this book because I thought – wow, what kind of mother brings her child to the US only to turn around and force her to work in a sweatshop? I could wrap my head around a mother owning and running a sweatshop. I could even imagine having your child work in a sweatshop in a different cultural context (due to need, due to cultural expectations, etc…). But the usual immigration story is a desire for your child to have a better life than your own. How does that compute if your own life is owning the sweatshop? I had to find out.

Anna deftly uses this moment in her teen years as the way into telling her life story that is also simultaneously the story of her family, of immigration, of sweatshops, and of what happens when a family member is seemingly randomly selected as the one to be ostracized. Anna felt loved and wanted by her grandparents, but that all changed when she came to the US to join her mother, new stepfather, and two new half-siblings. But this is real life, not a fairy tale, so the change wasn’t instantaneous. To me, one of the most painful scenes of the book is the party the family threw when she arrived from China. Being able to bring a loved one over from China you had to leave behind was a real status marker and cause to be celebrated. How that party went awry and how the relationship with her mother started to fall apart was painful but eloquently told.

Of course because this is a memoir we never truly get to know Anna’s mother’s motivations. But we do get some of her perspective revealed through the case worker, case documents, and what Anna’s grandmother has to say about it. Anna is willing to explore the impact of intergenerational trauma on her mother, without excusing her mother’s actions.

Anna also explores the importance of belonging, and how that being denied outside of the family is even more important when it’s being denied inside of the family. Anna describes her role in her family as:

I was a ghost haunting a family that wanted nothing to do with me, and the loneliness left a tightness in my chest.

location 392

Yet she also explores being othered outside of her family as well. At school she’s different because she spends some time away attending a different school. (Her mother briefly sends her to boarding school in China). She also experiences being different when she goes away to college without any familial support. The fact that she has to advocate for herself, get herself declared independent from her family, that she has to struggle to find a place to go on winter breaks and more, these all serve to show how she doesn’t fit in. I thought this was a great example of ways that society should strive to be more inclusive, as we never know what people’s home lives are like.

Beyond exploring her family trauma, Anna also examines the two-pronged issue of sweatshop labor and workaholism as seen in many immigrant families. From her perspective, this starts out as a necessity and then becomes a way of being even when it’s not a necessity anymore. With regards to sweatshop labor, Anna points out how interesting it is that she could get out because of laws about child labor but somehow this same labor was acceptable among adults. She also talks about how much worse it is for those with no legal recourse, such as those working under the table. What are the societal issues that lead to someone working under the table and how can those be addressed?

There are no easy answers to the difficult questions and problematic situations described in this book. I think a strength of this book is how Anna points out abuse has to be really bad to be resolved in our country – whether talking about home abuse or work abuse – but there’s lot of other abuses that are still abusive that still hurt people’s souls that just keep happening with very little to no intervention. What makes people, workplaces, and cultures abuse some and not others is a central exploration of this book with no easy answers.

4 out of 5 stars

Length: 224 pages – average but on the shorter side

Source: Netgalley

Buy It (Amazon or Bookshop.org)

Support me on Ko-fi

View my publications

  1. August 10, 2021 at 11:36 pm

    Wow! This sounds like such an interesting read! Thank you for that lovely review!

    • August 12, 2021 at 11:18 pm

      Thanks for taking the time to comment! I hope if you pick it up you enjoy it.

  2. Carmen
    September 14, 2021 at 9:04 pm

    Having lived in China and Taiwan ,Korea I am not surprised the treament of a daughter, many in China are sold, even maimed to beg for beggars gangs,sold into prostitution.
    I was when I first arrived as a diplomat how Chinese parents would save themselves from a home fire leaving kids behind.
    What a face loss for her mother to writte about the neglect, beating ,abuse.
    I am more shocked that the grandmother that never worked in the USA gets Medicare, a total abuse .
    One can see it is a cultural behavior how women are treated.
    I read House in Sticks ,similar but with a vietnamese family,beatings,hunger, and working 12 hrs in the sweatshop at home.
    I give thanks to God daily for having born in a loving culture where females are treasured, where if a family has to choose who gets better education ,is the daughter or daughters that are chosen.
    In Korea it was appalling how easily girls were abandoned.
    They take multiple generations to acculturize and assimilate.

    • September 15, 2021 at 9:16 am

      Hi Carmen, thank you for sharing your perspective from your years of diplomacy work.

      I will just note that I think it’s important we all acknowledge that all cultures and peoples struggle with issues of abuse.

  1. August 14, 2021 at 10:32 pm

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: